Snarking Obsidian: Chapter 2

Previously on  Obsidian, Beautiful Teen Hideous Teen Katy explains why she’ll have no parental supervision for the duration of her impending alien romance, then discovers just how deeply Sexy Neighbor Douchebag can affect her libido/moral reservations against homicide.

Note: all direct quotes are either in bold or block-quotes. If something’s in quotation marks but not bold or block-quotes, it’s paraphrased snark.

Chapter Index


Oh hey, looks like we have a tradition in the making: chapters starting out as boringly as possible.

It took the entire drive into Petersburg for me to calm down. Even then there was still a hot mix of anger and humiliation swirling inside me.

I’ll just leave this totally unrelated bit of advice about showing vs. telling here.

Katy reaches the grocery store without incident, and pauses her small towns are the worst sneerathon long enough to share—let me count them—four whole sentences about the store’s front window display, apparently crafted entirely of missing person flyers for a pretty girl Katy’s age, last seen more than a year ago.

Is that a plot I smell? In the start of chapter two? Dare I hope?

Katy’s avalanching food into her basket like a Supermaket Sweep champion when a “soft female voice” says her name, startling her out of her singleminded focus on GingTFO. The female attached to that female voice is, she sees, “too beautiful to be standing in a grocery store,” a veritable goddess who “stood out like a sunflower in a field of wheat,” which is an oddly rural simile coming from someone who’s spent the entire book thus far moaning that she, a native of bustling Gainesville, Florida, is too metropolitan for this barbaric backwater.

FYI, by “like a sunflower” she means the girl has long, dark hair and brilliant green eyes. She also presumably has a compellingly muscular torso, because Katy immediately realizes the girl must be Douchebag’s sister. And she’s right: the girl cheerfully introduces herself as Dee, sister of Daemon.

Faced with Dee’s offering of friendliness and good cheer, Katy does what any other shy, friendless new kid in town would do: launches straight into bitterness over how obscenely attractive the siblings are.

And of course his sister would be as attractive as him. Why not? Welcome to West Virginia, the land of lost models. I was starting to doubt I was going to fit in here.

Dude, you’ve laid eyes on exactly two people.

I am tired to death of pretty protagonists who bristle and mope at the sight of other attractive people. Extra points off if they’re white, straight, cisgender, able-bodied protagonists wailing that they can’t possibly fit in with their white, straight, cisgender, able-bodied peers; they’re just such misunderstood social outsiders, woe.

Dee’s got a Hufflepuff glow about her, and her fingers are visibly antsy to start on their matching BFF bracelets (hers probably in pink and yellow, Katy’s in shades of gray and who the fuck needs friends). Daemon had apparently emergency-broadcasted Dee a bulletin with Katy’s destination, ETA, and physical description.

“I don’t think your brother likes me,” Katy says, and when Dee apologizes and admits he’s a moody dude, Katy decides befriending this lovely cupcake is less important than insisting she’s right about Daemon:

No shit. “I’m pretty sure that was more than being moody.”

Care to explain why your three-minute interaction with him makes you more of an expert on his moods and behaviors than his twin sister? No?

Dee, desperate to achieve her dream of matching BESTIE necklaces, explains her brother’s behavior (short version: he’s having a bad day, and even on good days he’s not a people person; Katy’s reply: a laugh and sarcastic “You think?” and oh my god I think I hate her), before diplomatically steering this shitshow of a conversation toward cleaner and friendlier ground: how happy she is to meet Katy, and how she’d worried she’d be a nuisance if she stopped by Katy’s house to introduce herself.

Katy replies:

“No, it wouldn’t have been a bother.” I tried to keep up with the conversation. She went from one topic to the next like someone in bad need of Ritalin.

Listen, Katy, Dee’s a charming conversationalist who’s trying to keep both of you happy and engaged. YOU’RE the one who’s failing at Human Interaction 101 with your self-absorption and lack of consideration of her feelings. And apparent inability to follow a straightforward and much-needed change of topic.

And oh my god, Dee tries to open up a bit and tell Katy about herself, and here’s Katy’s response:

“Be right back.” I headed over to the refrigerated section.

Katy literally walks away, what is her deal.

While I’m over here fuming, a little boy’s goofing around (which Katy manages to make about herself: “Sometimes being around children was the perfect abstinence program. Then again, not like I needed a program“), until his mother sees how close he is to Dee and immediately start hemmoraging plot-related anti-alien prejudice:

“Timothy, get right back here this instant! [ . . . ] What did I tell you?” she hissed. “You don’t go near them.”

Her eyeballs are lazering terror at Dee, who’s now looking a bit wan. Katy asks what’s that all about, and Dee dismisses it as a small town with weird locals, no biggie.

By the time Dee heads home, the girls have scheduled a gardening date for later that afternoon. I’d congratulate Katy on making a friend, except Dee’s clearly a lonely muffin desperate enough to settle.

Katy’s just getting into her car when alert: neck hairs indicate someone is staring. A stealthy glance around the empty parking lot reveals only an ominously tumbling tumbleweed. Oh, and a dude wearing a black suit and sunglasses looking at a missing person flyer.

All I could think of was Men in Black.

The only thing he needed was that little memory-wiper device and a talking dog. I would’ve laughed, except nothing about the man was funny.

Three questions. (1) Why would you laugh if literally nothing about the guy is funny? (2) Is this really the best excuse the book could come up with to reference aliens? (3) Men in Black is all you can think of, really?

Guys, the laziness of this book’s writing is amazing.

Scene change! Dee bops onto Katy’s porch, ready and eager to do some hardcore gardening. Katy notes that Dee’s wearing ridiculously impractical shoes and “an impish grin” which Katy claims makes her look like “a cracked-out Tinker Bell, considering how hyper she was.

I’m seriously hating Katy’s descriptions of Dee. And no, we haven’t seen any proof that Dee is high-energy; we just have to take Katy’s word for it, which you know is my favorite.

Dee opens the conversation with a humorous anecdote: as soon as she got home with her groceries, Daemon went all Tasmanian Devil on them. Katy lols appropriately and marvels that he can eat so much yet still be sculpted of the purest, most grindable VixSkin Platinum silicone (note from my husband: that search term is not safe for work, children, and certain families); Dee says yeah, hoovering up food with nothing to show for it is a family trait.


My envy was almost painful. I wasn’t blessed with a fast metabolism. My hips and butt could attest to that. I wasn’t overweight, but I really hated it when Mom referred to me as ‘curvy.’

(Oh thank god, our heroine isn’t actually overweight. I almost panicked there, thinking her likability rating would plummet from—wait let me check the stats—2% to Too Fat To Bother With.)

The girls chat a bit about Katy’s move, and Dee lets drop that she and Daemon also aren’t from around these parts and that they also conveniently live without parental supervision, and just before I fall comatose from boredom, the book rolls in a freak storm to ruin their gardening plans and cut their friend-date short.

The girls agree to try again tomorrow, and Dee scurries back home, pausing only to shout that she’ll tell Daemon hi for Katy. (Katy’s response: “NO DON’T.” Dee’s response: “TOO BAD LOL.”)

And hey, wow, Katy’s mom was casually eavesdropping in the kitchen, like a concerned and attentive parent. Katy calls her out on her momly tactics, and Mom winks, “How else am I supposed to know what’s going on?” then warns “there is no such thing as privacy,” which is getting my hopes up. Will Mom play an active role in Katy’s life after all? Can I be so lucky?



27 thoughts on “Snarking Obsidian: Chapter 2

    1. I’m glad I started it before you did, then! But, of course, I’m going to be painting it in my personal, horrified, furious light; maybe you’d end up loving it after all? If you do read it, you’ll have to tell me every detail of your response to it! (Until then, though, I’m so glad you’re reading and enjoying my snark! Trust me, these first two chapters are a bit dull, but things start picking up quickly from this point on. 😅)

      Liked by 1 person

  1. Yes! I was eagerly waiting for this post LOL. Perfection as I expected. I don’t remember Katy’s personality very clearly from when I read it a while back, but I think you’ve reminded me how dislikable she was. From the quotes that you’ve shared, she is such a drama queen and complains far too much for no particular reason. And her conversation skills are something to be desired. The writing is horrid and the characters need some WORK. The only one I think I liked by the end of the book was Dee haha.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Aw, hurray! FYI, I’ll be posting new chapters on on Mondays, Wednesdays, and Fridays; I’d tried posting five chapters a week with my Throne of Glass snark, but nearly died of exhaustion. Here’s hoping a three-days-a-week schedule works for everyone. 😅

      Oh, I loled at the idea of “Katy’s personality.” I’ll confess I’ve read through the first eleven chapters (and have rough drafts of each chapter’s snark written), and I still don’t know what her personality is. The only traits I’d add to your list are “insecure, naive, self-absorbed, and hungry for dick.” Which is, uh, charming.

      I’m genuinely not surprised that Dee’s the only enjoyable character of the book. So far, I just want to adopt her and show her a better life, the poor cupcake.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Bless. Just what I need on my Mondays, Wednesdays, and Fridays LOL. I hope this scheduling works out a lot better for you, too!

        Yeah, Katy was a hard one to figure out. I don’t think I’ve ever read such a badly drawn character. She’s all over the place. And I highly approve of those added traits, especially that last one LOL. Dee deserves so much better than Katy, her brother, that town, and the book in general haha.

        Liked by 1 person

  2. I loved this chapter recap so much! I’ll admit I’m starting to see Katy in a different light and even I’m getting a little annoyed with her. I hate it when the protagonists act as if there’s some unforgivable flaw with their bodies when the only reason is that there is a super-attractive model–like boy who’s caught their attention. Give us some actual diversity right?
    Also reading about Katy’s and Dee’s interaction through your review really made me laugh. I can’t wait for the next chapter recap, and to see what you think of Katy in chapter three! 😀

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I’m so glad! It was kind of a dull chapter, so it’s good to hear my recap didn’t put you to sleep. Don’t worry, chapter three (which’ll go up Friday) is, uh, significantly more exciting.

      Yeah, I don’t have a very good impression of Katy so far–and I’ll admit that because of that, I’m more likely to highlight her faults than her good points. I’ll try my best to highlight her strengths as well as her weaknesses, whenever I come across them!

      And YES. I hate that too; it sends such awful messages to readers.

      Thank you so much for the encouragement! ❤

      Liked by 1 person

      1. It definitely didn’t put me to sleep. I am certainly interested in seeing your recaps when the plot starts picking up though, and seeing your reactions on more of the Katy/Daemon interactions! I do kind of love your comments on Katy so far though, she probably has some good qualities but I guess it’s more fun to complain about the (many) things that aren’t as good about her character I’m certainly seeing her in a new light.
        I’ll keep an eye out for chapter three then. 😀

        Liked by 1 person

      2. Oh, good. I’m just as excited for the plot to kick in as you are! It’s genuinely neat that we got a whiff of the plot in chapter two, with the missing person flyers.

        So far, the only good traits I can come up with for Katy are (1) her desire to help her mom, both physically and emotionally, and (2) her attempts to ignore Daemon and let his cruelty roll off her back. Both of those are incredibly admirable traits, and I should highlight them more often!


        Liked by 1 person

      3. Hopefully in the net few chapters you’ll get more of the plot and this story will speed up a little for you! 🙂
        Actually yeah they are good traits, and maybe you’ll see them more in the book as well. I know we’ve seen a lot of Daemon/Katy interaction so far but it doesn’t seem like we’ve seen a lot of Katy and her mum. If I’m remembering the book right, it’s been a long time since I picked it up myself!

        Liked by 1 person

  3. Hahahaha nice start with the showing not telling snark! Hahaha yes- hate the “woe is to me for being so attractive” nonsense! Hahaha I think this kid Katy has serious social issues! Hahaha I actually like the reference to MIB- it’s just so freakin’ obvious it’s actually hilarious- I mean she’s actually outdoing Stephenie Meyer at stupid- at least Meyer never said “he looked at me like Count Dracula… but I have no idea why I just said this cos I have no idea Edward’s a vampire” (seriously- I know I said this in your last post- but I’m having Twilight flashbacks!!) Loving this- can’t wait for chapter 3!!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. It must be such a terrible burden, being attractive. I’m so glad Katy’s up to the challenge of describing how awful it is, at length, repeatedly.

      YES to the social issues. I wanted to make a joke about her not being taken to the dog park often enough when she was young, but comparing women to dogs makes me deeply uncomfortable, no matter how apt the socialize-your-puppy comparison is. 😅

      The MIB reference definitely made me bark a laugh, for exactly that reason! The obviousness is hilariously dumb.

      Aw, thank you! ❤

      Liked by 1 person

  4. I was thinking to highlight my favorite snarks from this post but it’s not going to happen… I love and agree with everything you said/wrote… Thank you soooo much for doing this because I haven’t had that much fun following a blog before… it’s been fun, yeah, but this here deserves a freaking medal!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. My face is hot from blushing so much, Liz. I can’t tell you how relieved I am that you’re enjoying it. Thanks for being so sweet and supportive! Snarking is actually kind of hard for me, so the encouragement means a lot. 😊

      Liked by 1 person

    1. Ahaha, I think I’d probably get a punch to the face if I handed an author snarky line-by-line critique of their unpublished work. But seriously, editing YA novels is my dream job; I’d do just about anything to break into that industry. (Snarking published works might not be the best way to go about it!)

      I do! He’s the funniest, nerdiest Hufflepuff you’ll ever meet. He’s the best. 😊

      Liked by 1 person

      1. That’s an amazing dream, and I hope you can make it happen! I’d read the books you publish, that’s for sure–even if I wasn’t hired on to edit them. (Though that’d be pretty amazing, too!)

        Aw, yay! 😊

        Liked by 1 person

  5. OMG. The author did take the fast lane for everything in this book! I really want to comment on everything you said but… everything is perfect so I’ll just nod and say ‘yes! yes! yes!!!” to it. Kathy has serious social skills issues. Is it supposed to make her look like usual teens? Because I know a few and despite their irritating mood changes and sulking faces, they don’t usually leave in the middle of a conversation xD Everything is too obvious in this book, if the rest of it looks like that, it’s gonna be a fun snarking ride!!!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. This book is in the fast lane, for sure. I’m curious to see if and when it slows down. If it doesn’t, will they be married by the end of the book? I don’t think I could handle that.

      Maybe the teens you know are just unnaturally polite? 😄

      “Obvious” is such a perfect word to describe this book. Here’s hoping it provides endless entertainment!


What do you think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s