Rogue Magic (ARC)

Rogue Magic by Kit Brisby 3 star reviewRogue Magic
Kit Brisby
3 Star Book Review

Hey Katie,

Check it out, my second ARC! This one has magic and gay guys and super important anti-bigotry messages. And—check it out—a good rating from me, holy heck.

It’s Rogue Magic by Kit Brisby (whom I erroneously assumed was a gay male author, whoops), and will be released for purchase tomorrow, January 30. I received my advanced reader copy from Riptide Publishing, who graciously smiled upon my NetGalley request. Thanks, Riptide! Of course, no matter how much I appreciate them, even the most gracious smiles won’t affect my review or rating.

Book synopsis

While trapped in a stalled subway train on his morning commute, PR rep Byron Cole flirts with Levi, a young waiter with adorable curls. But Byron’s hopes for romance crash and burn when Levi saves him from a brutal explosion—with outlawed magic.

When Levi is imprisoned, Byron begins to question everything he’s ever believed. How can magic be evil when Levi used it to save dozens of lives? So Byron hatches a plan to save Levi that will cost him his job and probably his life. If he doesn’t pull it off, Levi will be put to death.

Byron discovers that he isn’t the only one questioning America’s stance on magic. And he learns that Levi is stubborn, angry, and utterly enchanting. Time is running out, though. Byron must convince Levi to trust him, to trust his own magic, and to fight against the hatred that’s forced him to hide his true nature his entire life. The more Levi opens up, the harder Byron falls. And the more they have to lose.

Spoiler free book review

Let’s make this quick, starting with the good stuff:

  • It’s a story featuring gay men and magic, heck yes.
  • The romance isn’t instalove, is treated with care and respect, and doesn’t overwhelm the plot.
  • The world it’s set in is a fantastical, alternative America in which mages (people with magic) are treated as sub-human. This version of America felt all too realistic and terrifying, and I was instantly emotionally engaged with Levi and the nameless, subjugated mages across the US.
  • The stakes (for the protagonists specifically and American mages as a whole) are both clear and very high throughout the novel, which kept me reading (too) late into the night.
  • The story’s message, its heart, is incredibly important—especially now, as leadership of the US has been taken over by a host of upper-class white bigots who care more about businesses than people.

And some bad stuff:

  • The pacing was wonky; it started off much too fast, which had serious, negative repercussions for the strength of the story as a whole.
  • There was very little world-building, and the story’s realism and the message’s power both suffered as a result.
  • The characters were stereotypes who stayed obediently within their stereotypical roles, and some important characters were eye-rollingly one-dimensional.
  • The story was predictable throughout; the events, characters, romance, even the bit of info that was supposed to be a surprise, all unfolded exactly as I expected them to.

The book really does suffer from its technical shortcomings (which I’ll expand on just a little bit more below); but I am in love with this book’s message, and would definitely recommend it.

Spoilery book critique

Spoiler Rating: Lots of big spoilers, beware

Book review criticism


The first portion of a novel (maybe quarter-ish or less, generally?) has a lot of work to do; it introduces the world, the characters, the upcoming conflicts, and—this is super important—sets up the foundation for the protagonist’s character arc.

I went into this story expecting to, you know, be shown the world, meet our protagonist Byron, and see him casually living his (socially conditioned, unquestioned) anti-magic bigotry. After all, shedding that bigotry is the character arc the synopsis had laid out for him. That character arc will only be convincing and powerful if we actually see him being an unthinking bigot first.

But nope. I actually thought my copy was missing a few chapters at the beginning because it skips the world/character/conflict/arc set-up phase entirely, and throws the reader right into the main conflict.

Here’s what happens in the first chapter (which, according to my ebook version, is eight pages long):

  • Byron meets and feels attracted to Levi,
  • there’s a terrorist bombing (supposedly carried out by rebel mages; these bombings are a regular occurrence across the US),
  • Levi uses his magic to save Byron (and a bunch of other people) from being explosioned to death,
  • having thus been revealed as an unregistered mage, Levi is brutally attacked by police and imprisoned by The Evil Corporation (a.k.a. Cole Industries, founded and led by Byron’s uncle),
  • and Byron begins to wonder oh, hey, is American society doing a terrible wrong by labeling all mages evil criminals whose magic needs to be suppressed and whose basic human rights need to be stripped?

You read that right. Within the first eight pages of the book, Byron’s already had his First Major Character Arc Revelation—something that typically doesn’t happen until closer to the one-fourth-ish or one-third-ish point of a novel. And by the one-ninth point, Byron’s wholly converted away from bigotry and is risking lives (more than just his own!) to carry out his Save Levi From Evil Cole Industries plan. One-ninth. If the novel had adhered to a more standard pace, it should’ve still been in the middle of the set-up phase.

I won’t lie, what excited me most about this book (aside from the fact that it’s a gay novel with magic) was the prospect of watching Byron slowly change from casual bigot to pro-mage activist as a result of meeting/falling in love with Levi. But that change took all of two seconds, and as a result his arc felt both shallow (to me) and unearned (for Byron). I was crushed.

Oh Yeah, the World-Building

Unfortunately, we’re given almost no information about magic or its history—and seeing as how the whole point of this book is to highlight how awful it is for a society to view some of its own people as sub-human, I really needed to know more about how this level of prejudice developed.

And I really needed more info on how the Evil, Anti-Magic Cole Industries gained the power it has—especially because Cole Industries is orchestrating the so-called “terrorist bombings” that have been killing hundreds (and injuring thousands) in major cities across the US every year, and blaming those bombings on rebel mages, and the US government knows and is totally cool with Cole Industries doing this, because the bombings drive up the public’s fear of mages and . . . uh . . . perpetuates the bigotry that keeps Cole Industries rich enough to pour its money into the government? I have no clue, guys. This all sounds deeply implausible to me, and only additional world-building would help me make sense of it.

Book review praise

So why am I recommending it?

Hell Yes, the Message

I can’t praise the book’s message enough, guys. In light of recent, president-related events that make me nauseous to even allude to, our global need of anti-bigotry, anti-corporate-greed, pro-human-rights, call-to-action stories has shot up from God Yes We Need Them to WRITE ALL OF THEM, PUT THEM ON ALL THE READING LISTS.

And honestly, I do think that (in an explicitly message-focused book like this one) having a powerful, necessary message is more important than having characters and a plot that are full of twists and surprises. Sure, twists and surprises would’ve made for more engaging reading, but the lack of them doesn’t necessarily diminish the power of the message.

Not the Plot I Expected

There are (as I’ve grumped about before) approximately billions of stories about rebels fighting against The Conquerors/The Government/The Evil from the outside, and that’s what I expected this book to become. I was waiting for Levi and Byron to escape Cole Industries, join up with other rebels, and fight Cole Industries from the outside.

Instead, we watch as Levi is tortured and experimented on, as he confronts his impending death, as he (with Byron and just a few others) scrapes up the terrified courage to do whatever little thing he can to bring Cole Industries down from the inside.

And yes, I know there are other “rebel is drawn into the heart of The Evil and takes it down from the inside” stories, but off the top of my head I can only think of one (An Ember in the Ashes) that upset me—to the point of turning my stomach, even—as I watched what happened to said rebel inside said Evil’s lair. Most of the other stories involve a half-hearted attempt at subjugating the lower classes, some ridiculous subterfuge, maybe a few explosions, and a great deal of angsty romance.

I’d be much less hesitant to pick up rebel stories if I knew they were going to be as grimly realistic as this one.

Slow Romance, Sign Me Up

The romance between Levi and Byron didn’t quite blow me away, but I loved how it began with vague attraction and very, very slowly grew into something more—and that both men acknowledged (out loud!) that it’d be pretty messed up/morally questionable to enter into a romantic relationship while Levi’s still imprisoned by Cole Industries.

See, Byron is the nephew (and sole living relative) of Warren Cole, founder and leader of Cole Industries, the wildly powerful company that develops and produces anti-magic technology, and is tasked with containing/neutralizing all magic in America. Byron works for Cole Industries as a PR rep, which isn’t a prestigious job, but his relationship with Warren gives him extra power in the company.

Levi, on the other hand, is a prisoner/lab-rat confined to Cole Industries laboratories, where he’ll be experimented on (and tortured) to death.

There’s a severe power imbalance in their relationship that only Levi’s freedom can correct. The men acknowledge that, and try to resist falling into a relationship. They fail, but hey, I’m thrilled that the book spelled out This Could Be A Potentially Abusive Situation for the reader.

Book review in closing

Honestly, I don’t read capital-M Message Books very often, and this is definitely one of those. I prefer my books to present quieter themes and messages while their protagonists, you know, flail swords from atop their dragons and whatnot. If I’d known that Rogue Magic was a Message Book, I might have been a little less inclined to read it.

So I’m glad I didn’t know. I needed to read this, and I’ll bet others need to as well. We need these call-to-action books, and we need them everywhere.

But I’m struggling to rate this book, guys.

It’s somewhere between two and a half and three and a half stars, for sure. If I was rating it as a regular novel, I’d probably give it two and a half; it kept me engaged, but its shortcomings are significant and frustrating. But because it’s a Message Book, and it’s a message I’m especially invested in (and I’ve been in a heightened state of Horrified Fury since the election) . . . I don’t know, guys. I think I’m going to go with three stars, and the acknowledge that it might deserve an extra half star. This is a book with a heart of gold.



15 thoughts on “Rogue Magic (ARC)

  1. All things being equal, I think I do find myself enjoy books that start off with a bang rather than build exposition and info-dumps to lead into the conflict. But this would usually only be successful if there’s content afterwards that expands on the feeling of “oh shit conflict”.

    Levi is awfully close to Liam. Would you ship yourself with Bryon? Food for thought.

    Curious. You found that you enjoyed that the romance led the way to change/betterment? I’m not always “for” books where romance is the main crutch for protagonists to do 180-degree flips but maybe that’s just me and my cynicism.

    Anyhow, thank you for your spoilers…because spoilers.

    Glad to see you being an eager [honorary Canadian] beaver with finally enjoying a book for a change!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I definitely agree that books should start (as immediately as possible) with something that’ll nail my butt to my chair; I also think that that thing shouldn’t also immediately take the protagonist’s character arc from “Beginning/Normal State” to “TOTALLY CHANGED,” especially when that character arc is as integral to the story’s message as Byron’s arc is. If this book started off exactly the same way (with the bombing), but Byron’s change from bigot to ally-risking-his-life-for-American-mages was a little more gradual, I’d have been happy as a clam.

      Ha! No, I wouldn’t ship myself with Byron; I’m actually having a hard time thinking of a fictional character I’d ship myself with other than Mr. Knightley from Jane Austen’s Emma. Uh. Not much of a self-shipper over here, apparently.

      “I’m not always ‘for’ books where romance is the main crutch for protagonists to do 180-degree flips but maybe that’s just me and my cynicism.”

      No, I totally agree; if a book is all “But he’s so DREAMY, how can his people possibly be evil??,” it’s going to lose me too. Fortunately, this book doesn’t rely on romance as a crutch for Byron’s arc; Byron’s immediately attracted to Levi, yep, but it’s Levi’s willing self-sacrifice (to save countless of people who fear and hate mages) that convinces Byron that mages aren’t inherently evil. Byron only starts actually falling in love with Levi well after they’ve been working together for a while to save Levi from the Evil Corporation. So have no fear, Joey, this book handles this situation quite well.

      I’m more excited about being an honorary Canadian than enjoying a book for once, I’m not gonna lie.


    1. I’m so glad you enjoyed it! I’ll be interested to read your review of it, when you post it.

      Yep, I suspect we’re thinking of the same thing here. Well, at least the book wasn’t being marketed as a mystery, and its synopsis didn’t claim it’d be full of twists and turns. =)


  2. I skimmed your spoilers on the off chance that I end up picking it up, and I must say, it sounds quite interesting. I don’t often read Message books either (although I guess most books do come with a message) and might be more lenient towards them, but I can see why the character development came a bit too soon – like, you don’t even really know the character yet to know that a line of thought is out of the ordinary for them!

    I also quite enjoy slow romances. In my experience, a relationship can be a good catalyst to character development… just as long as it’s written with realism and it doesn’t overtake the whole plot. Great review, Liam! 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Yeah, characters need at least a little bit of time in the beginning to establish their “base existence/mentality” before they begin their change, because how else will the reader know the character well enough to really appreciate that change? Bah.

      “[A] relationship can be a good catalyst to character development… just as long as it’s written with realism and it doesn’t overtake the whole plot.”

      Exactly! I love watching how characters change as a result of the relationships (romantic or platonic) they establish, but (in my opinion) too many stories get so wrapped up in the romance that they forget to flesh out the characters’ arcs.

      Thanks, Reg!


  3. It sounds as if the author was afraid of running out of pages and rushed the thing! The beginning doesn’t make much sense, especially in the genre. That’s too bad because gay men and magic, you have a lot to do with this!! I enjoy seeing a character grow too much to pass on this, it’s a shame.

    Liked by 1 person

  4. This sounds like a really interesting read! I don’t think I’ve read many message books and so it’d me be cool to explore that a bit, but I’m a little hesitant to pick this one up. The bad things you pointed out, such as strange pacing, weak world-building, stereotypical character profiles, and predictability are all things that bother me the most haha. But the good aspects of the book seem very promising, especially the slow-burn romance (which is always a welcome change from insta-love) and the powerful message. I’m on the fence, but thanks for bringing my attention to this one, Liam! Great, review as always 😀

    Liked by 1 person

What do you think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s